Readings for today: Acts 15-16
One of the most concerning trends in recent years in the church in America is the lack of submission to godly authority. The unwillingness to submit to godly discipline. To refusal to let anyone hold any real authority to confront us, challenge us, and ultimately require us to step back from ministry. I see it in several celebrity pastors who were dismissed from ministry, disqualified by the church boards where they once served, but who refused to go through any kind of restoration process and simply popped up in a different location to launch new ministries. They often monetize their sin. Writing books. Recording podcasts. Building platforms on social media. All to share their stories of “brokenness” but what’s so often missing is any kind of humility. Any kind of serious, concrete repentance. Instead, they often blame the church for their sins. Blame the culture of the church for their mistakes. Blame the people of the church for being too harsh and judgmental for attempting to hold them accountable. But it’s not just the celebrity pastors for whom this is true. I’ve seen it in my own community as well. Pastors who fall into sin and yet refuse to submit to any formal discipline process before restoring themselves to ministry. The issue could be heresy or false teaching. It could be a moral or spiritual failing. It could be abuse or neglect of others. It doesn’t really matter. The point is they refuse to submit. They refuse to be humble. They refuse to do the hard work of being restored to God, to their families, and to the larger church community. Instead, they simply choose to move on.
This was not the pattern in the early church. Acts 15 makes it clear that the early church had a clear authority structure. Leaders were accountable to other leaders. No one was “too big” to fail. Peter had to defend his actions in eating with Gentiles. Paul and Barnabas had to defend the doctrine of grace over and against the Jewish believers who wanted to require the Gentiles to follow the Law. Together, the early church leaders sought the will of God by searching the Scriptures, passionately debating, hearing both sides of the argument, and then praying for the Holy Spirit to bring unity. Listen to how the first church council described it in a letter to the early church, “For it seemed best to the Holy Spirit and to us…” (Acts 15:28a NET) Clearly, they submitted to the Lord and clearly, they submitted to one another out of reverence for Christ.
Martin Luther once wrote that the three “marks” of a true church are where the Word is rightly preached, sacraments rightly administered, and church discipline rightly enforced. Sadly, that last “mark” is all too often missing in our churches today. We do not regularly discipline our members. We do not regularly discipline our leaders and pastors. And the result is the world gets a distorted, even perverted view of Christianity because of the sin we tolerate in our lives and in our church communities. Furthermore, even in those extreme cases where the church is forced to discipline those within her midst, the lack of humble submission becomes yet another sign to the world that the church is full of hypocrites. It’s heartbreaking. It’s why Brennan Manning famously once said, “The greatest single cause of atheism in the world today is Christians: who acknowledge Jesus with their lips, walk out the door, and deny Him by their lifestyle. That is what an unbelieving world simply finds unbelievable.”
Readings for tomorrow: No devotionals on Sundays